Understanding where solvency ii is heading fs regulatory centre of excellence, 3 august 2011 4 other technical amendments parliament. In both cases, movements in spread are explained primarily by changes in illiquidity premium. Unlike solvency iis matching adjustment, where business is defined as matched or not, the degree of liquidity is important. The illiquidity risk premium systemic risk and systematic value. The impact of solvency ii capital requirements, compared to current bases used in pricing technical issues such as the interpretation of contract boundaries and epifp the allowance made for illiquidity premium in pricing and profitability analysis the impact of diversification benefits and capital.
Solvency ii and the search for the true discount rate. Through the introduction of an illiquidity premium, intransparent concepts are applied to. Dealing with the occurrence of negative liquidity spreads. Based on that methodology, eiopa finds that the degree of illiquidity of the liabilities amounts to 72%. Liquidity denotes the ease with which an asset can be traded. Tegelijkertijd zijn het interest rate volatility risk en equity volatility risk verwijderd. Janka schuld joint iaca, iaahs and pbss colloquium in hong kong. Illiquidity premium who, when and how determines it. The purpose of this paper is to describe the main features of the solvency ii standard formula.
The illiquidity discount should be decrease as the time horizon of the investor holding the asset increases illiquid assets should be valued using higher discount rates riskreturn model. The qis5 draft specifications foresee the following simple formula for the. Unexpected losses credit risk premium and 3 illiquidity premium. While financial institutions have faced difficulties over the years for a multitude of reasons, the major cause of serious banking problems continues to be directly related to lax credit standards for borrowers and counterparties, poor portfolio risk management, or a lack of attention to changes in economic or other. Ceiops comments on qis5 draft technical specifications. Unlike solvency ii s matching adjustment, where business is defined as matched or not, the degree of liquidity is important. Sii matching adjustment institute and faculty of actuaries.
Balance sheet resource requirements are highly sensitive to the illiquidity premium ip source. Risk adjusted asset cashflows v liability cashflows800. Illiquidity risk is increasing and in fact linear in solvency uncertainty, as measured by the standard deviation of ex post returns. But the illiquidity premium is an adjustment to asset values, not liabilities.
Solvency ii and the search for the true discount rate the journey so far. Article 75 of the solvency ii framework directive directive 20098ec states \liabilities shall be valued at the amount. Discount rate risk free plus illiquidity premium risk free plus illiquidity premium potential grandfathering arrangements in solvency ii would significantly differ from ifrs. Upon declaration by the regulator the european insurance and occupational pensions authority that distressed market conditions exist, an additional wedge is to be added to the risk free term structure to value all insurance liabilities subject to fair market valuation. Systemic risk and the solvencyliquidity nexus of banks. The illiquidity premium is the higher yield investors can find by investing in bonds that are lightly traded. The pricing of illiquidity as a characteristic and as risk 153 compensation for the expected cost of illiquidity. Prem illiquidity premium risk exposure increase in the value of the technical provisions due to a decrease in the matching premium. The market risk under solvency ii the market risk module includes the following submodules. Entering the final countdown towards solvency ii summary the omnibus ii directive is the directive which, once approved by the council of. The illiquidity discount should be decrease as the time horizon of the investor holding the asset increases illiquid assets should be valued using higher discount rates risk return model. Illiquidity and portfolio risk of thinlytraded assets.
In particular the complementary identification code cic is a solvency ii 4character alphanumeric security identification code. Sensitivity and dynamics of ifrs 17 illiquidity premia. Cash management group solvency ii and money market funds. Ica allows for illiquidity premium early solvency ii pure market consistent, no allowance for illiquidity qis 5 illiquidity premium. The degree of liability illiquidity might end up being banded.
Illiquidity premium of the insurers matching assets, with an adjustment for credit risk. When the liquidity premium is high, the asset is said. Illiquidity premium, marketconsistent valuation and solvency. This is generally not appropriate for longterm insurers. Wuthric h march 16, 2011 abstract the insurance industry currently discusses to which extend they can integrate an illiquidity premium into their best estimate considerations of insurance liabilities. Entering the final countdown towards solvency ii fs regulatory centre of excellence, 30 april 2012 2 implementation date solvency ii implementation timetable both parliament and council propose that the full requirements of solvency ii should be implemented from 1 january 2014.
A useful feature of the illiquidity premiums observed from the risk free asset is that they can be used to develop a illiquidity discounts via the cost of capital for a private company. Ceiops comments on qis5 draft technical specifications 1. The october 2011 solvency ii draft introduces the possibility of a countercyclical premium. Report on longterm guarantees and measures on equity risk. The following white paper was prepared by christian laux at the center for financial studies for a workshop on liquidity premium in solvency ii. Solvency ii standard formula and naic risk based capital rbc report 3 of the cas risk based capital rbc research working parties issued by the rbc dependencies and calibration working party dcwp abstract.
International association of insurance supervisors, 2018, instructions. Concluded that illiquidity premium did not fully address the. Liquid risk free curve liquidity premium bottomup discount rate liquidity premium. Share of future discretionary benefits and future premiums. The conclusion that there is no illiquidity risk without solvency uncertainty is an intuitive one, but not present in many models and much discussion of illiquidity risk. Solvency ii highlights the importance of the market risk. The liquidity premium is the difference in the price the spread of two identical assets with different liquidities. However, the very late date at which omnibus ii is now. First things first, an illiquidity premium and a liquidity premium are basically different ways of describing the same thing. Wuthric h april 15, 2011 abstract the insurance industry currently discusses to which extent they can integrate an illiquidity premium into their best estimate considerations of insurance liabilities.
Directive level 1 implementing measures level 2 implementing technical standards level 2. Entering the final countdown towards solvency ii pwc uk. Headline verdana boldbermuda reporting requirements. Difference between solvency risk and liquidity risk finance essay. See naic instructions for precise statement of the rule. This also further supports the objective of avoiding excessive volatility in solvency ii and stabilizing capital resources for insurers both from a supervisor and management perspective. The illiquidity risk premium is an excess return paid to investors for tying up capital. Conceptual and measurement issues, at dnb amsterdam in march 2011. Under solvency ii, standard formula, european insurers apply a solvency capital requirement of 3% per year of modified duration for all unrated assets including sme loans, leveraged loans, and commericial real estate. Instead, solvency ii focuses on risk measurement and management, and applies. Eiopa has investigated the illiquidity of insurance undertakings from two different perspectives. Sii matching adjustment an industry view 5th november 2012. On top of this riskfree rate, eiopa allows under specific circumstances to add a volatility.
Identical assets have the same characteristics duration, risk, cash flows, etc. Ceiops would like to point out that the illiquidity premium is only one. Solvency ii longterm guarantee measures are aimed at reducing the effect of artificial volatility for. Ifrs 17 why actuaries need to care life2017 2122 june 2017 qe11 conference centre, london. Solvency ii standard formula and naic risk based capital rbc report 3 of the cas risk based capital rbc research working parties. These risk adjusted return measures are then used alongside a solvency ii style capital model to generate capitaldriven investment metrics.
Pdf illiquidity and portfolio risk of thinlytraded assets. The pricing of the illiquidity factors systematic risk by. The x and y are chosen to best match three primary methods currently used by practitioners to estimate the illiquidity premium in financial markets. Incidentally, it is very hard to separate from credit risk. Jul 16, 2016 the illiquidity risk premium is an excess return paid to investors for tying up capital. The qis5 exercise shows the following results as at 31 december 2009. Following the submission by ceiops of its draft technical specifications for. To encourage insures, reinsures and supervisors to prepare the introduction of solvency ii and to identify areas where internal processes, procedures and infrastructure may need to be. An implication of this literature is that systemic risk is likely to play a key role in the solvencyliquidity nexus through the liquida. This chart is intended for illustrative purposes only, and does not represent an opportunity to invest, actual risk and return can look materially different. As a solvency ii equivalent jurisdiction, bermuda adopts a three pillar approach to risk based supervision. In addition to pillar i requirements for solvency ii, insurers will need to consider the pillar iii reporting guidelines with regards to their mmf holdings. In addition to discussing methods for estimating an illiquidity premium, we have also considered the potential impact that any future change in the illiquidity premium might have on an insurer.
Report on insurers asset and liability management eiopa. In other words, the illiquidity increases when the market is down. The introduction of solvency ii will improve risk management and help firms understand the risks in a different way, but we also have to consider the implementation costs. These numbers could be compared to solvency ii where eiopa define. The overall purpose of the solvency i pillar 2 illiquidity premium and solvency ii ma is to allow. An academic view on the illiquidity premium and marketconsistent valuation in insurance mario v. Under stable market conditions, the model produces stable estimates of credit risk and slowly varying illiquidity premia. Until very recently and within the scope of solvency ii, liquidity risk was only.
Liquid risk free curve illiquidity premium gross yield on reference portfolio allowance for uncertainty. Again, there is variation across lines of business and between member states. Solvency ii standard formula and naic riskbased capital rbc. Illiquid assets and capitaldriven moodys analytics. For the cad portfolio in particular, the credit component of the spread is almost constant. Ifrs 17 credit and illiquidity premia dec 18 moodys analytics. The committee for european insurance and occupational pension providers ceiops has proposed allowing the use of an illiquidity premium for assessing capital levels for annuity providers existing business, in its latest round of solvency ii implementation advice, which was published this week. An academic view on the illiquidity premium and market. The premium compensates the investor for forfeiting the options to contain marktomarket losses and to adapt positions to a changing environment. The illiquidity premium is calculated by reference to a portion of the spread not attributable to expected. It is true that illiquid assets carry an illiquidity premium, which, if held to maturity, disappears. Having a massive solvency ii programme in place, the budgets can be quite significant. If an illiquidity premium is used by an insurer, then under apras proposed capital principles the risk that such illiquidity premiums adversely. Solvency ii replaces the current solvency i regime, which is based on prudent assumptions.
Insurers asset and liability management in relation to the illiquidity of their liabilities. Infrastructure debt to capture the illiquidity premium. Cfo forum backs liquidity premium for mcev and solvency ii. Institute of actuaries of australia abn 69 000 423 656 level 7, 4 martin place, sydney nsw australia 2000.
Countercyclical regulation in solvency ii 3 figure 1. Illiquidity premium, marketconsistent valuation and. For professional clients only not for public distribution. That is the netofcost return on an asset must be higher than the netofcost return on the asset which is next to it in terms of lower cost. The solvency ii riskfree term structure is derived using a prescribed.
In terms of model 1, rjk, increases as a function of sj. Illiquidity premium, marketconsistent valuation and solvency in insurance mario v. The solvency ii quantitative impact study 5 qis5 specifications did set out a methodology to estimate illiquidity. Using illiquidity premiums on the risk free asset to measure. Iies 2017 lessliquid fixed income investments spectrum of liquidity and credit risk note. Eiopa must not have the power to determine arbitrarily. Permitted approaches for constructing ifrs 17 discount rates. The iml, adjusted for the common risk factors, measures the illiquidity premium whose annual alpha is about 4% over the period 19502012. We also note that in europe for qis5 for solvency ii a formula of 50% of spread 0. Ifrs 17 why actuaries need to care willis towers watson. Solvency ii standard formula and naic riskbased capital. Risk margin solvency i framework solvency ii framework solvency ii balance sheet asset liability technical provisions scr.
Insurers file a capital and solvency return csr within four months of. Although the term illiquidity premium is used in the context of solvency ii, liquidity premium is more widely used and easier to understand. Volatility adjustment under the loop deloitte united states. If an illiquidity premium is used by a life insurer, then under apras proposed capital.
The risk margin is part of the technical provisions under solvency ii. The areas considered in this paper are equity risk, premium risk, credit risk, dependencies within premium and reserve risks, the overall risk aggregation process, operational risk. How will the ifrs 17 discount rate impact the balance sheet. Illiquidity premium as in qis5 now divided in 2 components level 2 draft matching premium. Although the proposal to introduce a liquidity premium in solvency ii has been updated, the discussion of the concept of a liquidity premium and the. Dec 28, 2012 solvency ii and the search for the true discount rate the journey so far. Product strategies under solvency ii and ifrs 4 phase ii. Insurers asset and liability management in relation to. Liquidity premiums working party bob gore carl dowthwaite may 2014. Risk free rate illiquidity premium expected default default risk premium figure 1. He is a member of the iabe and currently works for the risk management department at.
89 273 101 321 737 324 12 1630 1494 487 366 382 1286 103 1049 1576 1188 480 456 487 599 345 742 622 377 348 1171 959 1020 1340 299 912 955 485 1041 793 629